10 Vintage 80s and 90s Toys Worth a Fortune Now
Nostalgia is a powerful force, especially when it comes to the toys of our childhood. For those of us who grew up in the 80s and 90s, certain toys that bring back warm memories have also become incredibly valuable over the years. Whether you’re a collector looking to reminisce, or an investor seeking a potential goldmine, check out these 10 Vintage 80s and 90s Toys Worth a Fortune Now.
1. Pikachu Illustrator Card
Original Price: Part of a contest, not sold
Current Price: $5,275,000 (Logan Paul’s purchase)
Year Released: 1998
Manufacturer: Pokémon
Why Valuable?: One of the rarest Pokémon cards, with only 39 in existence. The Pikachu Illustrator Card is one of the rarest Pokémon cards in existence, making it a holy grail for collectors. This card was released in 1998 as a reward for a Pokémon illustration contest in Japan. Only 39 copies were ever made, making it exceptionally rare. The card features Pikachu holding a paintbrush. It’s known for its unique artwork that differs from the standard Pokémon card design. Its scarcity and the lore surrounding its distribution have fuelled its legendary status among Pokémon enthusiasts and card collectors alike.
Did you know? The Pikachu Illustrator Card holds the record for the most expensive Pokémon card ever sold at public auction. Influencer Logan Paul acquired a PSA Grade 10 Pikachu Illustrator card for $5,275,000. This purchase was completed through a record-breaking trade that involved exchanging a PSA Grade 9 Pikachu Illustrator card valued at $1,275,000 plus $4,000,000 in cash. The transaction set the record for the most expensive Pokémon trading card sold at a private sale. This purchase highlights the card’s cultural significance as a symbol of the global impact of the Pokémon franchise.
2. De Beers 40th Anniversary Barbie
Original Price: N/A
Current Price: $85,000
Year Released: 1999
Manufacturer: Mattel
Why Valuable?: Encrusted with 160 diamonds, making it incredibly rare and valuable. The De Beers 40th Anniversary Barbie, released in the 1990s, is not just a doll but a dazzling piece of art. This Barbie was a collaboration between Mattel and the diamond company De Beers to commemorate Barbie’s 40th anniversary. This iteration of Barbie was never made available for retail. It was sold directly at auction to an undisclosed bidder. She is adorned with a gown that features 160 genuine diamonds. Easily making her one of the most luxurious and sought-after Barbie dolls ever produced. This lavish use of real diamonds in a children’s toy set a new standard for high-end collectible dolls.
Did you know? This Barbie doll’s creation was a landmark moment in toy history. It merged the worlds of traditional children’s playthings with the luxuriousness of fine jewellery. The De Beers Barbie’s gown is designed to showcase the elegance and timeless beauty of diamonds. It captivates both doll collectors, and jewellery aficionados. This doll’s release was a bold move that blurred the lines between toy and treasure. The De Beers Barbie is a unique and extremely valuable collector’s item.
3. Nintendo 64
Original Price: $199.99
Current Price: A sealed unit listed for $250,000
Year Released: 1996
Manufacturer: Nintendo
Why Valuable?: Nostalgia and rarity of pristine, unopened units. The Nintendo 64, launched in 1996, revolutionized the gaming industry with its innovative three-dimensional graphics and multiplayer capabilities. It brought to life some of the most iconic video games of all time. Perhaps most notably “Super Mario 64,” and “The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time.” The console’s unique controller design, with its analog stick, allowed for unprecedented precision and control in video games. Its success laid the groundwork for future gaming consoles and solidified Nintendo’s reputation as a leader in the industry.
Did you know? A pristine, unopened Nintendo 64 console can fetch astonishing prices on the collector’s market. Some listings reaching up to $250,000. The Nintendo 64’s nostalgia factor and its role in advancing 3D gaming make sealed units incredibly valuable to collectors. It’s not just about owning the console; it’s about preserving a piece of gaming history. The rarity of finding a console in such condition decades after its release contributes to these high valuations. While not every Nintendo 64 will reach the quarter-million mark, special editions like a factory sealed Pikachu-themed Nintendo 64 system, are listed at $5,999.99. There currently exists a high demand and value for unique and well-preserved pieces.
However, it’s crucial to note that while some listings may reach these astronomical figures, actual sales prices can vary greatly. For instance, a sealed copy of “Super Mario 64” sold for a record-breaking $1.56 million. Proof that collectors are willing to pay top dollar for rare and iconic pieces from the Nintendo 64 era. These instances underscore the collectors’ market’s unpredictability and the significant premium placed on nostalgia and rarity.
4. TMNT Scratch The Cat Action Figure
Original Price: $8.99
Current Price: $4750
Year Released: 1993
Manufacturer: Unknown, part of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles franchise
Why Valuable? Rarity, especially for a character that only appeared in the video game. The Scratch The Cat action figure is one of the rarest and most sought-after pieces of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles memorabilia. Released in the early 90s, Scratch The Cat is a villain from the expansive TMNT universe, known for his jailbird motif. His action figure was produced in limited quantities, making it incredibly rare and highly prized among collectors. The scarcity of the Scratch The Cat figure, combined with the enduring popularity of the TMNT franchise, has driven its value to remarkable heights.
Did you know? Scratch The Cat’s rarity is due in part, to its release late in the toy line’s run. It was released at a time when fewer stores were stocking TMNT figures. This timing meant that fewer Scratch figures were produced and sold, making them a rare find today.
Mint condition figurines have sold for $4750. Current ebay listings can have as high of an asking price as $7999.
5. Star Wars the Glasslite Vlix Figure
Original Price: ?
Current Price: $5,000 – $20,000 when out of its original packaging. In its packaging, $45,000 – $60,000.
Year Released: 1987
Manufacturer: Glasslite
Why Valuable? The Star Wars Glasslite Vlix figure, produced by Glasslite in Brazil in 1987, is one of the rarest commercially released action figures. Initially intended for release by Kenner for the Droids cartoon series, the figure’s molds were sold to Glasslite after the show’s cancellation. Vlix figures, made in a small batch, became highly valuable, especially due to a recall and rumoured warehouse fire. This scarcity has significantly increased its value. The economic situation in Brazil during the late 80s further contributed to the toy’s rarity. Many were unsold and then subsequently stored or destroyed. It comes as no surprise that a Star Wars Collectible toy would be on a list of vintage toys worth a fortune. It is surprising at how rare this toy is though. The story behind the toys production added to it’s value arguably more than the Star Wars lore about it.
Did You Know? The term “Vlix” became an inside joke at the production company Nacelle. It symbolizes something good that needs to be cut for the greater good. The value of a Glasslite Vlix figure varies significantly based on its condition, and whether it’s still in its original packaging. Figures out of their original packaging can sell for between $5,000 and $20,000. Those still in their packaging can command prices between $45,000 and $60,000.
6. Magic in the Cards: The Black Lotus Phenomenon
Original Price: If found in a pack, a few dollars; if purchased separately: $22.50
Current Price: In pristine condition: well over $100,000 at auction, with even lesser conditions selling for tens of thousands
Year Released: 1993 as part of the game’s first core set (Limited Edition)
Manufacturer: Wizards of the Coast
Why Valuable? Magic: The Gathering – a game that turned tabletop battles into a worldwide phenomenon, introduced us to many valuable cards, none more so than the Black Lotus. The Black Lotus’s value comes from its rarity. Only 1,100 were ever printed in the alpha deck. Its game-changing abilities give players a significant advantage. Its status as the “holy grail” of Magic cards cements its place in the hearts (and wallets) of collectors worldwide.
Did you know? A particularly notable sale involved rapper Post Malone, who purchased a signed artist proof Black Lotus for over $800,000. A Beta Black Lotus artist proof also recently sold for $615,000 at auction. These sales highlight the card’s high demand among collectors, especially for versions autographed by the card’s artist, Christopher Rush.
7. Atari 2600 Air Raid
Original Price: Not specified due to its rarity
Current Price: $33,433.30 for a truly complete game
Year Released: 1982
Manufacturer: Men-A-Vision
Why So Valuable?: Air Raid’s value stems from its extreme rarity, being the only game released by Men-A-Vision. It’s distinguished by its blue T-handle design. Only a handful of copies are known to exist, contributing to its high collector’s value. The game features the typical 8-bit graphics common in video arcades and home gaming at the time.
8. G.I. Joe Cobra Command Team Leopard Paint Variant Destro AFA 90
Original Price: $8.99
Current Price: $6,801
Year Released: 1997
Manufacturer: Hasbro
Why So Valuable?: Its value comes from its rarity and the unique story behind its production and distribution. Originally painted as a joke, a designer at Hasbro fell in love with the concept and greenlit a small batch to be produced. Only a few hundred were produced, with approximately 100 accidentally shipped to the USA, making it a rare collector’s item from the 90s.
Did you know? This particular variant of the Destro figure is known among collectors as ‘Pimp Daddy’ Destro due to its unique paint variant.
9. Cabbage Patch Kids – James Dudley
Original Price: $22.99
Current Price: up to $3,000
Year Released: 1985
Manufacturer: Coleco
Why So Valuable? This doll, characterized by its blond hair, blue eyes, and sporting a red and blue sports jersey with the number 31, alongside matching blue and white shoes was amongst the first dolls released. Cabbage Patch Kids dolls, particularly rare editions from the 1980s like James Dudley, have seen their prices soar. Their value stems from the unique adoption process and individualized nature of each doll, making them highly coveted.
Did You Know?: The Cabbage Patch Kids dolls were originally created by Xavier Roberts. They were first introduced to the market in the early 1980s by Coleco, a company that specialized in video games and electronic devices. After Coleco, the brand saw various manufacturers over the years, including Hasbro, Mattel, and Play Along Toys, each taking a turn producing the beloved dolls.
10. Nintendo 64 GoldenEye 007 WATA 9.0 A+
Original Price: $69.95
Current Price: $1995 – $2495
Year Released: 1997
Manufacturer: Nintendo
Why So Valuable?: GoldenEye 007 for the Nintendo 64 was a cultural phenomenon that revolutionized first-person shooters on home consoles. I logged a few hours on this game any chance I got to play it at a friend’s house. Our family didn’t own a Nintendo 64, or else I would’ve played until my eyes were bloodshot and my thumbs ached. It was a really fun game to play (unless you were playing someone who was way better at the game; then it sucked ‘cause they’d kill you repeatedly before you barely even moved). A GoldenEye 007 N64 video game, factory sealed and graded by WATA at 9.0 A+, is listed for $1,999.99. Highly graded, sealed copies of this iconic game can indeed reach such high values. This game is amongst some of the most ground-breaking in the industry that has gone on to influence the modern realm of esports.
Did You Know?: GoldenEye 007 was groundbreaking for its multiplayer mode, which was almost cut from the game during development. It went on to become one of the most beloved aspects of the game.
Where to Buy These Collectibles
For collectors interested in purchasing these vintage treasures, eBay remains a primary marketplace. However, specialized auction sites like Sotheby’s, heritage auctions, as well as collectible toy shops, are also valuable resources for finding these items.
Conclusion
The value of vintage toys from the 80s and 90s has skyrocketed, thanks to a combination of nostalgia, rarity, and cultural significance. Whether you’re holding onto these toys from your childhood, or looking to start a collection, their worth is more than just sentimental. It will be interesting to watch these 10 Vintage 80s and 90s toys worth a fortune now, to see if they continue to increase in value. You may want to dig through your attic, or keep an eye on auctions to find some of these gems. Who knows? You might just own a piece of history worth a fortune.
Share Your Stories About Collecting 80s and 90s Toys
I can’t imagine ever having the foresight and the discipline to purchase toys when they are released and not open them while waiting to see if their value skyrockets. It must be tough to go to great lengths to safeguard their pristine condition for years, sometimes decades, while hoping your initial investment will pay off. Are you a collector? What surprised you on the list? What is missing from this list that is now worth a fortune? Leave a comment below. Looking forward to hearing from you!
Have a rad rest of your day!
FAQs
Can I still find these toys for sale?
Yes, you can still find these vintage toys for sale, though it may require some effort. Online marketplaces like eBay, Etsy, and specialized collectible websites are good starting points. Auction sites, including Sotheby’s and Heritage Auctions, sometimes list rare vintage toys. Collectible toy stores, both physical and online, as well as conventions and trade shows dedicated to collectibles, are also excellent places to find these items.
How do I verify the authenticity of a vintage toy?
Verifying the authenticity of a vintage toy involves several steps. First, research the toy to understand its characteristics, markings, and packaging. Manufacturers often include specific details that can help identify genuine items. Consulting with experts or joining collector forums can also provide insights. For high-value items, consider seeking a professional appraisal or verification service that specializes in collectibles. The item’s history of ownership, can also help confirm authenticity, especially for items sold through reputable auction houses or dealers.
Are there any other toys worth collecting that aren’t on the list of 10 Vintage 80s and 90s Toys Worth a Fortune?
Absolutely! Beyond the toys listed, the 80s and 90s produced numerous collectible toys worth noting. Examples include Transformers, original LEGO sets, American Girl dolls, and early editions of Magic: The Gathering cards. Other notable mentions are Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles figures, early Super Soakers, and Micro Machines. Each of these toys not holds nostalgic value and is a significant part of toy history and pop culture, making them sought-after items for collectors.
Craig is a partner, and proud father of a teenage daughter, and two dogs. He's an avid blogger who loves researching and discussing 80s and 90s nostalgia. When not working on his website or hanging with his fam, Craig enjoys playing guitar, watching lacrosse, and being near water.